The Impact of AI on SEO: Why SEO Is Still as Important as Ever

A couple of years ago, if we’d spoken about the impact of AI on SEO, I don’t think anyone would have foreseen just how widespread it’s become. You can’t take a step on the internet now without stumbling across another AI SEO tool, or post after post about SEO is dead, long live AI, or how we should run away from every and all AI usage. The reality is, AI is here. It’s part of our lives now. So, should we chuck out our previous SEO strategies in favour of a gung-ho AI approach, or stick to what we’ve always known? The answer is… it depends (sorry; once an SEO, always an SEO, and all that). But it’s certainly not straightforward. Let’s take a look at how AI fits into the SEO landscape in 2025.

HOT TOPIC

AI generated content

This is where you’ve probably encountered the most heated debates. On the one hand, you’ve got “if you can’t beat them, join them” attitudes with teams pummelling out AI generated content in the hopes that the quantity over quality approach will get them ranking. This can work – we’ve seen it – but it isn’t sustainable and we usually see the negative implications after a few months.

Just like any tech industry, this area is rapidly evolving. It’s not just drivel being produced now; generally decent content can result from AI prompts.

Due to the ease of creating this passable content, AI generation has infiltrated so much more than just the blogging world. We’re seeing tools like Wix, Yoast, and the WordPress Elementor plugin, all jump on the AI bandwagon. From AI generated meta titles and descriptions to entirely AI website copy, you name it, it’s been introduced. You can even get AI generated websites – code and all – if you’re happy to pay.

On or off the bandwagon?

AI can save you a lot of time. But what it lacks is the side of SEO that has become more and more important in recent times. And that’s the E-E-A-T principle.

“Google Search’s guidance on AI-generated content has changed… to allow for AI content creation, provided it meets the same quality guidelines established for human writers.” - Search Engine Land

The content produced by AI will always lack the human touch and emotion that really drives readership. It can’t replicate a company, or a person’s, own experience. So when Google is looking at content or websites to rank, it’s looking at all elements of the E-E-A-T guidelines. If it detects a high usage of AI, this is going to undermine pretty much all aspects of those guidelines and reduce trust in your website.

USE IT WISELY

The power of AI to simplify and speed up tasks

The combination of AI and SEO isn’t black and white. There are many ways it can optimise your workflow.

Don’t have time to write all your meta titles and descriptions by hand? Then yes, absolutely let Yoast’s AI write them for you. Something is better than nothing and we know that well-crafted meta titles and descriptions do make a difference, but they aren’t the be-all and end-all of your SEO strategy.

Got an idea for a blog but can’t quite work out where to start? ChatGPT an outline. Have a conversation about your blog’s purpose and harness the suggestions. Not sure why an existing blog isn’t performing very well? Ask AI.

AI is improving many of the tools we SEOs use on a day-to-day basis. SEMrush, SEranking, and so many more are now using AI to improve keyword research tools or to give complex predictions that would be otherwise difficult to do.

It’s important to explore these and other ways to integrate AI into your process without resorting to using AI content generation to flood your website or socials with meaningless content.

The new normal

AI in search

We’ve talked about a zero-click Google for a very long time, and the dawn of the AI generative search result has only raised the profile of that discussion further.

These AI generated results sit at the top of the search results page and attempt to answer your query or give information about a topic you’ve searched for before you even hit the much-desired top ten links.

When these were first introduced, they were everywhere, and they were, to quote Dr Pete Meyers, “bland at best, and inaccurate at worst”. Since then, Google has scaled these back and started providing sources.

AI GENERATED OVERVIEWS

The AI impact on search

According to this May 2024 study, these AI generated overviews have impacted the search landscape in a variety of ways:

Click below to expand

The study found AI overviews appearing in 42% of searches. This is much more than some predictions, however, this could have decreased since as we’ve seen some scaling back of the overviews.
Traffic seems to vary depending on the quality of the AI response and the search intent behind the keyword. Much like featured snippets, the AI overviews can sometimes encourage clicks through to the website cited or send fewer clicks than if no overview appeared.
These AI overviews are mostly targeting knowledge-seeking queries, which is understandable. This is why they are so reliant on search intent.

Race to the top

Those sources/links credited within the generative AI response are becoming the new position zero. Along with visibility above the fold, they also show that Google’s AI algorithms are trusting your content enough to use it as part of its answer. Whether this has any knock-on effects to the actual search engine is yet to be seen, but we can assume that very similar signals are used.

“I found a very strong correlation (0.917) between sites that show up in the top 10 organic results and sites cited in AIOs for the 1,675 keywords.”

These overviews, along with featured snippets, are all ways to get the information to the user as fast as possible. So it makes sense to optimise for these overviews if possible. Google’s John Mueller confirms that:

“I think AI type answers make sense for a lot of queries and that’s going to be frustrating for some sites that focus on those queries, kind of like with featured snippets as well. And that also provides a lot of opportunities.”

So, no matter what you might think about the quality of these AI overviews, optimising for them clearly comes strongly recommended.

Of course, these overviews also instructed some users to use glue to stick their cheese to their pizzas, so we’re all still learning.

time to take action

Using AI as part of your SEO strategy

It’s clear from what we’ve discussed above that using AI as part of your SEO strategy can enhance your ability to optimise content, analyse data, and adapt to changing trends in search algorithms.

AI powered or assisted tools can automate time-consuming tasks such as keyword research, meta description creation, and content optimisation and creation, allowing you to focus on strategic planning and creativity.

Predictive analytics driven by AI can help you anticipate shifts in user behaviour, enabling you to target emerging trends before your competitors. Additionally, AI can analyse massive amounts of data to identify patterns and insights, helping you craft the right content for your audience. By integrating AI into your SEO workflow, you can achieve greater efficiency, scalability, and accuracy.

But there are common pitfalls involved with relying on AI, so to ensure these are smartly sidestepped, it’s important to keep an eye on:

Click below to expand

Don’t just blindly trust your AI results.

Please.

Content should be checked and verified. This means fact-checking as well as running your final content through an AI checker to see just how much AI content is being used.

Leaving obvious errors in your content is going to undermine your trust and authority – directly impacting your SEO efforts.

If you’re relying on SEO for your content creation, ensure you’re allocating human oversight to the results to ensure those human emotions and perspectives are captured properly.

While the rise of AI undoubtedly impacts the digital landscape, SEO remains a critical component of a successful online presence. However, 84% of marketers said that AI tools are “very effective at aligning web content with search intent”. These days, with the continual messaging from Google about “helpful content”, this is one of the most important areas in SEO.

So: AI augments SEO strategies rather than replacing them.

Wondering how AI fits into your own SEO strategy?

Companies need to stay updated on AI advancements and work hand in hand with SEO experts to navigate this evolving landscape and maintain their competitive edge in the digital realm.

Book a no-obligation chat with Natalie to discover how AI can improve your SEO strategy.