Impact Reporting for Charities: Why your story matters & how to deliver a strong report

As a charity trustee and B Corp agency owner, I’ve witnessed firsthand how remarkable work often goes uncelebrated in the third sector. The Charity Commission’s recent call for organisations to “stop being shy” about their impact gets a yes from me as I view impact reporting from both sides of the fence.

FIRST THINGS FIRST

Why Impact Reporting Matters Now More Than Ever

The Charity Commission’s chief executive, David Holdsworth, has clarified that demonstrating impact isn’t just about ticking boxes anymore; it’s about building and maintaining public trust. In an article published in late 2024 he shares that research consistently shows that people care deeply about how charities spend money and achieve their purposes.

SO WHAT"S THE PROBLEM?

The Hidden Challenge in Impact Reporting for Charities

Here’s what I’ve learned from both perspectives: charities often struggle not because they lack impact but because they’re too close to their own story, often working with limited resources, and for many, they just haven’t considered impact reporting before.

When you’re deeply embedded in the day-to-day running of a charity, it’s surprisingly easy to overlook the significance of what might seem like routine achievements and how they might provoke support, endorsement and donations.

Common Roadblocks in Impact Reporting:

FIRST THINGS FIRST

Turning Data into Stories That Matter

The sweet spot for impact reporting lies in storytelling. Through our work with purpose-driven organisations, we’ve discovered that the most compelling impact reports don’t just present data – they weave together a narrative that connects numbers with real-world change.

Best Practices for Impactful Reporting:

ONE:

Start with Your Core Mission

Begin by clearly articulating your charitable purpose and how your activities align with it. This creates a framework for your entire report.

TWO:

Embrace Both Quantitative and Qualitative Impact

Numbers matter, but so do stories. The most effective reports balance statistical evidence with compelling narratives about real people and real change.

THREE:

Document the Journey, Not Just the Destination

Numbers matter, but so do stories. The most effective impact reports for charities balance statistical evidence with compelling narratives about real people and real change.

FOUR

Tell people about it

Remember this crucial insight: for every hour spent creating your impact report, set aside the same time for distribution. With studies showing that both B2B and B2C decision-makers increasingly focus on sustainable and ethical practices, getting eyes on your report should be a priority.

Remember, a single LinkedIn post won’t suffice. Your impact report represents significant work and insight—give it the distribution strategy it deserves.

Consider these distribution channels:

Resource Alert!

Here’s a practical checklist of distribution considerations for your impact report.

Looking Ahead

The Future of Impact Reporting

The Charity Commission’s planned changes to reporting requirements present an opportunity rather than a burden. By making the impact more visible, charities can:

  • Build stronger connections with supporters
  • Attract new funding opportunities
  • Inspire other organisations
  • Strengthen public trust

Taking Action

Next Steps for Your Charity

Review your current impact measurement practices

Identify gaps in your documentation

Consider how to capture both planned and unexpected positive outcomes

Think about creative ways to present your impact story

FINAL THOUGHTS

Your Story Deserves To Be Told Effectively

As someone who straddles both the corporate and charitable sectors, I’ve seen how powerful well-crafted impact reporting can be. It’s not just about compliance – it’s about celebrating your achievements, learning from your experiences, and inspiring others to join your cause.

The time for being shy about your impact is indeed over. Your work matters, and your story deserves to be told effectively.

Need help crafting your impact story?

As a B Corp agency with extensive experience in impact reporting and a deep understanding of the charitable sector, we’re uniquely positioned to help you share your impact story effectively. Learn more about our impact reporting services below.